Great story. After a car wreck in which one car landed on my engine hood, I had a fractured writs, among other minor problems, fortunately. Was in college, so learned to write with my left hand, after six weeks it was legible enough to write checks fairly easily, not as good, but it worked till the cast was cut off.

Based on the above would say it was the first one, the top one, that's what mine looked like after about a month.